Fewer than 5 people recommend it so far, so there's no written verdict. Here is what commenters said.

3recommend
2warn against
Apr 29, 2026first mention
Oct 28, 2026latest mention
Nov 25 – Oct 26
Used foremacs rewrite in rustgpu-accelerated emacs

Why people recommend it

“It seems pretty readable and well-structured”

“I think a stronger basis for that is probably the Neomacs project”

Show 1 more

“Hopefully Neomacs”

Caveats and dissent

“looks like its suffering from never ending scope creep”

Often compared with

From the makers not counted in the ranking

“I'm busy on the development of neomacs”

“I once wrote yet another over ambitious project”

All comments 6

“looks like its suffering from never ending scope creep”

It's ironic that a community that uses a program originally developed at the MIT AI Lab, extensible in the traditional programming language of AI, would hate AI. Richard Stallman prefers to call AI "Pretend Intelligence". https://github.com/SimHacker/moollm/blob/main/designs/PRETEND-INTELLIGENCE.md Richard Stallman proposes the term Pretend Intelligence (PI) for what the industry calls “AI”: systems that pretend to b

“It seems pretty readable and well-structured”

“I think a stronger basis for that is probably the Neomacs project”

“Hopefully Neomacs”

Threads where it came up

Also written as NEO Emacs, neomacs. Data: neomacs.json. Quotes are verbatim; the verdict and theme labels are written by a model from these comments, and every clause links to its sources.

Keyboard shortcuts
j / kNext / previous item
o or EnterOpen selected item
/Search
g hHome
g tTop
g rRising
g cCategories
tToggle dark mode
?This help